This is by and far the worst book I’ve read all year. I’m not sure why it got such good reviews from the critics. NPR loves Austin Grossman, which is where I first heard of the book. They gave him an interview on Weekend Edition and put him on the summer ‘07 recommended reading list. PRI’s Sound of Young America interviewed him as well. I can’t figure out what their fascination is with him. This is the only book he’s written and it’s terrible. In the interviews Grossman seems to be very pleased with how clever he is. He’s soooo cool for writing about superheroes as real people. Never mind that Alan Moore, Neil Gaiman, Frank Miller, Kurt Busiek, etc. have been doing this for decades prior. There’s nothing wrong with being unoriginal, but if you’re going to copy do it well. Grossman does an anemic job at best in this genre. Grossman credits his experience in the video game industry for his abilities to write. He’s the one who writes those cut scenes in video games, you know, the ones you skip through so you can keep on blasting away zombies and aliens? Being proud of video game writing is like being proud of writing screenplays for porn films. Not exactly Academy Award winning work.
The worst problem with this novel is that it can’t decide what it wants to be. Is it a gritty superhero noir tale of superhuman powers with human fallibilities and problems? Is it a comic farce? Is it a page-turning plot-twisting thriller? Unfortunately it’s none of these. Instead it’s 288 pages of lengthy esoteric exposition. Apparently Grossman comes from the tell, don’t show school of writing. The book is written in first person narrative, which is difficult to do well, and Grossman falls down on the job. His characters spend all their time narrating endless drawn-out soliloquies to themselves (and unfortunately you have to listen as well). What depresses me is that there are probably thousands of better manuscripts lying in desk drawers and hard drives unpublished, while this chump gets his drivel published and hyped up on NPR. I’m no super writer, this blog is evidence of that, but at least I’m not trying to push my drivel as awesome fiction. Consider yourself warned. Don’t believe the hype.

